21 Best Amish Recipes To Try Today
When it comes to hearty, home-cooked meals, few do it better than Amish recipes. These dishes, passed down through generations, are the perfect blend of simplicity and flavor, making them ideal for any occasion.
Whether you’re craving comforting stews, freshly baked bread, or sweet treats that warm the soul, Amish cooking offers something for everyone. These time-tested recipes are perfect for family gatherings, cozy dinners, or just a taste of tradition.
So roll up your sleeves, gather your ingredients, and let’s dive into some of the best Amish recipes that will bring warmth and deliciousness to your table!
21 Best Amish Recipes
1. Amish Chicken and Noodles
Imagine a cozy kitchen filled with the aroma of savory chicken broth!
This dish is a beloved comfort food featuring tender egg noodles tossed with moist, shredded chicken and a medley of vegetables.
It’s the perfect meal for a chilly evening, reminding you of grandma’s cooking. Serve it up with crusty bread to soak up all that luscious broth! Trust me; it’s like a warm hug in a bowl.
Recipe: Amish Chicken & Noodles
2. Amish Potato Salad
This isn’t just any potato salad—it’s a classic dish that brings all the flavors together in perfect harmony!
Creamy and tangy, this salad combines tender potatoes with hard-boiled eggs, a hint of mustard, and a sprinkle of fresh herbs. Ideal for picnics or potlucks, it’s sure to be the star of the table. A scoop of this will make anyone feel like they’re at a family gathering!
Plus, it’s best made a day in advance, allowing those flavors to really shine.
Recipe: Amish Potato Salad
3. Amish Bread
There’s nothing quite like the smell of freshly baked bread wafting through your home! Amish bread is soft, slightly sweet, and perfect for slathering with butter.
It’s a simple recipe that yields a fluffy, warm loaf that pairs beautifully with every meal. Make a slice for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and watch it disappear! Trust me; you’ll want to keep this recipe close at hand.
Recipe: Amish White Bread
4. Amish Baked Oatmeal
Start your day off right with a warm bowl of Amish baked oatmeal!
This hearty breakfast is not only delicious but also keeps you full with wholesome oats and a touch of sweetness.
Toss in your favorite fruits or nuts for added flavor and texture, and bake it until golden brown. It’s perfect for meal prep—just reheat and enjoy for days! Pair with yogurt or milk, and you’ve got a winner for the whole family.
Recipe: Amish Baked Oatmeal
5. Amish Peach Pie
Nothing says summer quite like a slice of fresh Amish peach pie! Bursting with juicy peaches and a hint of cinnamon, this pie is encased in a flaky, buttery crust that crumbles delightfully with each bite.
Serve it warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, and you’ll feel like you’ve just arrived at an Amish farmhouse.
It’s a slice of heaven that proudly showcases the fruits of the season! Perfect for family gatherings or a sweet treat after dinner.
Recipe: Amish Style Fresh Peach Pie
6. Amish Casserole
This hearty dish embodies everything comforting about Amish cooking! Combining layers of meat, vegetables, and creamy goodness, this casserole is both filling and flavorful.
You can easily customize it with your favorite ingredients, so no leftovers go to waste. Plus, it’s a great way to feed a crowd! Baked until bubbly, it’s sure to be a family favorite.
Recipe: Amish Casserole
7. Amish Corn Casserole
Prepare for cheesy, corn-filled bliss! This Amish corn casserole blends sweet corn with creamy goodness and a touch of cheese, making every bite a delight.
Simple to whip up, it’s a great side dish for any meal and perfect for gatherings. You’ll find yourself sneaking back for seconds, and trust me, nobody will judge! It’s like a party for your taste buds.
Recipe: Amish Baked Corn
8. Amish Snickerdoodle Cookies
Get ready to indulge in these cinnamon-sugar delights! Amish snickerdoodle cookies are perfectly soft with a slight crunch, practically melting in your mouth.
They’re rolled in a delightful mix of sugar and cinnamon before baking, creating a sweet, aromatic finish.
Ideal for dunking in milk or sharing with friends, they’re a nostalgic treat that can bring back childhood memories. Get your apron ready, because one batch won’t be enough!
Recipe: Amish Snickerdoodle Cookies (thin and crispy)
9. Amish Macaroni and Cheese
Say goodbye to box mac and cheese—this Amish version is creamy, cheesy, and oh-so-satisfying!
It’s made with real cheese and a few secret ingredients that elevate it to gourmet status. Perfect for a family dinner or a side dish for a BBQ, this pasta will have everyone raving.
It’s comfort food at its finest! Just remember to save some for leftovers; it tastes even better the next day!
Recipe: Baked Macaroni and Cheese-Amish
10. Amish Vegetable Soup
Warm up with a steaming bowl of Amish vegetable soup! Packed with fresh vegetables and seasoned to perfection, this soup is healthy and hearty.
It’s a great way to use up whatever veggies you have on hand, making it both economical and delicious. Serve it with a slice of homemade bread, and you have a meal that warms the soul.
It’s like a garden party in a bowl!
Recipe: Amish Beef and Vegetable
11. Amish Schnitz Pie
Get ready for a slice of tradition with schnitz pie, a unique Amish dessert! This pie is filled with dried apples, spices, and a hint of sweetness, all wrapped in a flaky crust.
It’s a delightful way to enjoy the flavor of fall any time of year! Each bite is both comforting and nostalgic, transporting you to cozy evenings on the farm.
Serve it warm with a scoop of ice cream or whipped cream, and watch it disappear faster than you can say “schnitz!
Recipe: Apple Schnitz Pie
12. Amish Shoofly Pie
Step into the sweet side of Amish cooking with shoofly pie, a dessert that’s as fun to say as it is to eat!
This pie features a rich molasses filling with a crumbly topping that creates an irresistible sweet and sticky treat. Traditionally made for breakfast or brunch, it’s perfect with a hot cup of coffee.
It’s a unique pie you won’t find just anywhere, making it a must-try for adventurous eaters. Each slice is a true testament to Amish baking traditions!
Recipe: Amish Shoofly Pie
13. Amish Green Bean Casserole
Forget the canned versions—this Amish green bean casserole is made from scratch and bursting with flavor!
Featuring fresh green beans, creamy sauce, and crispy fried onions on top, it’s comfort food that’s a hit at every gathering.
This dish proves that simple ingredients can come together to create something truly amazing. It’s great for holiday feasting or a cozy family dinner. You’ll find it’s hard to resist just one helping!
Recipe: Ultimate Green Bean Casserole
14. Amish Apple Butter
Who needs store-bought spreads when you can make Amish apple butter at home? This rich, spiced fruit spread is perfect for slathering on toast or pancakes and tastes like autumn in a jar!
Slow-cooked to caramelize the apples beautifully, you can customize it with your favorite spices. Jars of this homemade goodness also make thoughtful gifts for loved ones.
Enjoy spreading this delightful treat all year long!
Recipe: Amish Apple Butter
15. Amish Pumpkin Bread
Get ready to savor the delightful flavors of fall with moist Amish pumpkin bread!
This quick bread is loaded with pumpkin puree, warm spices, and often a sprinkle of nuts or chocolate chips for added texture.
It’s perfect for breakfast, snacks, or even dessert, and fills your home with a cozy aroma. Plus, it freezes beautifully, so you can enjoy it anytime. Slice it thick and enjoy with butter for a simple pleasure!
Recipe: Amish Pumpkin Bread
16. Amish Rivel Soup
If you’re searching for a comfort soup that’s easy to make, look no further than rivel soup! This hearty dish features tiny dumplings called rivels mixed in a flavorful chicken broth with vegetables.
It’s warm, filling, and downright satisfying—a perfect antidote for a cold day. Each spoonful feels like a warm embrace, making it a family favorite. Don’t be surprised if seconds are requested!
Recipe: Amish Rivel Soup
17. Amish Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup
Combine two classics for the ultimate comfort meal!
Amish grilled cheese sandwiches are made with generous amounts of melty cheese between buttery bread, perfectly grilled to golden perfection.
When paired with a hearty homemade tomato soup, it’s a match made in heaven. Perfect for lunch or a cozy dinner, this duo never fails to warm hearts (and bellies).
Remember, dipping those sandwiches in the soup is a must!
Recipe: Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup
18. Amish Pot Pie
Say hello to a dish that’s picturesque in flavor and presentation!
Amish pot pie brims with hearty meats, colorful vegetables, and a savory gravy all tucked into a buttery crust. Each slice is comforting and heartwarming, reminiscent of family dinners around a bustling table.
The best part? It’s versatile and can use whatever ingredients you have on hand. A true crowd-pleaser, it’s sure to earn rave reviews!
Recipe: Pennsylvania Dutch Chicken Pot Pie
19. Amish Chocolate Sheet Cake
Indulge in a slice of Amish chocolate sheet cake—a treat so moist and decadent, it will leave you craving more! This chocolatey delight is easy to bake, making it perfect for any occasion, from casual family dinners to birthday parties.
Topped with a rich chocolate frosting that just melts in your mouth, it’s the ultimate dessert for chocoholics. Pair it with a cold glass of milk, and you’ve got a winning combo!
Get ready to share this recipe, as everyone will be asking for it.
Recipe: Moist Amish Chocolate Cake
20. Amish Cinnamon Rolls
Start your mornings off right with homemade Amish cinnamon rolls that are soft, gooey, and downright dreamy!
These rolls are slathered with cinnamon and sugar, rolled up, then baked until they’re golden and fluffy. Drizzle with a simple icing, and you’ve got a treat that’ll brighten anyone’s day.
Whether enjoyed with coffee or saved for dessert, they’re a heavenly addition to any brunch spread. Pro tip: make a double batch—trust me, they won’t last long!
Recipe: Amish Cinnamon Rolls
21. Amish Coleslaw
Last but not least, let’s talk about Amish coleslaw—a surprisingly flavorful side dish! This crunchy mix of cabbage and carrots is coated in a creamy dressing with just the right amount of tanginess.
It’s a delightful accompaniment to any meal and is particularly adored at summer barbecues and family gatherings. You can easily tweak the recipe to add your favorite ingredients, like apples or raisins, for a sweet twist!
The crispness of the cabbage and the creaminess of the dressing makes every bite a refreshing experience. Whip up a batch, and watch it disappear from the table in no time!
Recipe: Amish Cole Slaw
You might also like to read:
